Friday, 8 March 2013

Why 'equality' is bad

'Equality', in its current usage, is so devoid of any precise meaning that it is utterly useless for anyone to appeal to equality when arguing for or against any position.

An iced bun and a jam doughnut are being sold for 50p each. Are they equal? Do they have equality?

Is this true?

Iced bun = Jam Doughnut

No, they're clearly different things. You can only lick icing off the bun. You can only get jam all over your fingers with the doughnut. In a normal day I will desire the bun far more than the doughnut. So they're not equal.

But despite this, they are equal in value. The baker has set their price to be the same, and my bunny preference is equalised by someone else's love for jam doughnuts.

The problem with 'equality' is that next to no one seems to be able to distinguish between these meanings any more.

One man earns £20,000pa and another earns £100,000pa.

What does equality require?

1. A charge of £20,000 per person.

2. A flat tax rate of 33% on all earnings.

3. The richer man to pay £40,000 to the government, the poorer man nothing.

4. The redistribution of the richer man's income - £40,000 to the government, and £20,000 to the poorer man (to even things up).

5. The redistribution of all both men's possessions and earnings so that they have exactly the same stuff- minus £40,000 paid to the government in administration fees.

Friday, 1 March 2013

Assorted thoughts on Eastleigh

As those in the know expected, the yellows won.

The real story though is the blues, purples and others. Diane James (ukip), Maria Hutchings (con) and Danny Stupple (ind) split the right of centre vote. All three were clearly opposed to the redefinition of marriage, demolishing the idea that such beliefs make you unelectable.

Under the AV system, either the blues or purples would have walked this election. This gives Farage real power heading towards 2015. UKIP could never have risen as they have with a properly functioning Conservative party. With this result they have to be taken seriously.

Cameron is making a strong case for himself as the worst Conservative Prime Minister in a very long time.

Thursday, 28 February 2013

Life on the lunatic fringe

I was interviewed last week; for the first and probably last time.

I had no more than 5 minutes to prep but I think I'm happy about what I said (and what was included).
But apparently my views qualify me as lunatic fringe. Christendom is apparently now the intellectual equivalent of drunk anarchism and the political philosophy of crumpetism. Islamism is wrong and abhorrent but even it has more philosophical merit than the dominant secularist socialism.

I think that my views, held by most of the western world for most of modern history, scarcely qualify as lunatic fringe. I don't know what the motives were for including my position in this article, but it doesn't take much brain power to figure out that the authors want to ridicule the views represented - both by name-calling and association.

Do you think I deserved my place in this list?

Why downrooted?

So why would a pedant like me (not 'I') choose a made-up word for the title of my blog?

My instinct in life has been to find a good opportunity and seek my fortune in a strange and distant land.

That's not how it's worked out though. Commitments, pressures and kindness has meant that staying rooted has made the most sense for me and Adele.

Psalm 1 describes the righteous man as 'like a tree planted by streams of water'. Jesus is the true Israel, the tree into which the Church is grafted. And we are trees ourselves, planted by streams of living water providing our spiritual sustenance.

Sometimes, staying right where you are is the best thing to do.

Given the right location, a tree need only grow deep, thick roots and it will grow tall, strong and healthy.

Wednesday, 27 February 2013

A blank page

I decided to start blogging from scratch.
---
A blank page is inviting; you can colour it however you like.

A blank page is intimidating; it needs lots of work.

A blank page is a relief; previous attempts left behind.

A blank page is dangerous; you alone are responsible for how it's filled.

---

Previous blogging has been theology-centred in topic. This time I hope to blog on topics as wide as my curiosity. So expect theology, politics, NFL, music, commuter dynamics and whatever else has recently piqued my interest.

I better start writing.